Jump to content

 

- - - - -

Would you still join a club each year?


28 replies to this topic

Poll: Would you still join a club each year? (35 member(s) have cast votes)

Would you join a club if the licence form didn't require it?

  1. Yes, I would join a club anyway. (30 votes [85.71%] - View)

    Percentage of vote: 85.71%

  2. No, I would save a few pounds each year. (5 votes [14.29%] - View)

    Percentage of vote: 14.29%

Vote Guests cannot vote

#1 Pete_Scorpa3

    Advanced Member

  • Site Supporter
  • 1,440 posts
  • Location:Evesham, Worcs.
  • Bike:Scorpa SY250
  • Club:Stratford-Upon-Avon MC&LCC

Posted 18 May 2011 - 05:51 AM

The ACU are looking into making licence (registration) applications easier and putting them online. :thumbup:

The one real stumbling block is how club membership secretaries sign the form prior to submitting it to the ACU.

One option is to 'do-away' with this need and simply ask riders which club they have joined.

We only charge £5 per year, but it's still valuable income when we have 80 members.

I wonder how many riders would still pay to join a club if they didn't need to, would you?

Any comments welcome.

Pete

#2 Blocky

    Advanced Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 275 posts
  • Location:Huntingdon UK
  • Bike:TY250 FM240
  • Club:Cambridge Matchless & Nene Valley

Posted 18 May 2011 - 06:58 AM

I voted no but its not about saving money.

#3 bilc0

    Advanced Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 832 posts
  • Bike:Fantic 50+ 200 + 240

Posted 18 May 2011 - 07:13 AM

Are the ACU saying this way you don't need to join a club or are they saying you still need to join a club but you don't need to do the yearly thing of collecting club stamps and signatures to get a licence.
I would of thought the club could still claim membership fees in order for one to ride there trials etc etc.

#4 PHB

    Advanced Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 306 posts
  • Location:north yorkshire
  • Bike:BETA EVO 250
  • Club:bradford & dmc

Posted 18 May 2011 - 07:52 AM

View Postbilc0, on 18 May 2011 - 07:13 AM, said:

Are the ACU saying this way you don't need to join a club or are they saying you still need to join a club but you don't need to do the yearly thing of collecting club stamps and signatures to get a licence.
I would of thought the club could still claim membership fees in order for one to ride there trials etc etc.

so how would you collect membership fees when the trial is a centre trial,as lots of riders will just say im a member of another club etc etc I am a membership secretary for my club and dont understand why anyone would find getting the ACU licence difficult, you fill in the form which is available on most clubs websites or the ACU'S site, send/give it to the secretary of your chosen club with the membership monies, simplles really isnt it IF ITS NOT BROKEN DONT FIX IT

Edited by PHB, 26 May 2011 - 03:21 PM.


#5 bilc0

    Advanced Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 832 posts
  • Bike:Fantic 50+ 200 + 240

Posted 18 May 2011 - 08:04 AM

View PostPHB, on 18 May 2011 - 07:52 AM, said:

so how would you collect membership fees when the trial is a centre trial,as lots of riders will just say im a member of another club etc etc I

You don't issue Club membership cards then?we are just talking about the once a year one off payment of £5 here arn't we.
Or just scrap the above and put afew extra quid on the Trial entry fees,this probaly would be a better idea anyway,making clubs having to put on a better trial to get there money.

#6 jordi

    Advanced Member

  • Site Supporter
  • 1,035 posts
  • Location:East Sussex
  • Club:Brighton & Dist

Posted 18 May 2011 - 02:08 PM

Surely if you do not join a club then clubs will slowly die away, then there will be no clubs to run trials :(

#7 PHB

    Advanced Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 306 posts
  • Location:north yorkshire
  • Bike:BETA EVO 250
  • Club:bradford & dmc

Posted 18 May 2011 - 03:12 PM

View Postbilc0, on 18 May 2011 - 08:04 AM, said:

You don't issue Club membership cards then?we are just talking about the once a year one off payment of £5 here arn't we.
Or just scrap the above and put afew extra quid on the Trial entry fees,this probaly would be a better idea anyway,making clubs having to put on a better trial to get there money.


we dont issue membership cards and i dont know of any yorkshire centre club that does ,but some clubs might, its hard enough getting £15 a trial out of some riders never mind putting a few extra quid on the entry fee, plus it may only be a fee quid to be a member but that money goes into buying flags scorecards etc, clubs are not charities.

#8 GIZZA5

    Advanced Member

  • Site Supporter
  • 1,641 posts
  • Location:Coventry/Scarborough
  • Bike:Mont 4RT/BMW 1150GS
  • Club:Scarborough & Earls Shilton

Posted 18 May 2011 - 03:42 PM

This old chestnut again and both discussions about club and licences can be talked about forever.
There are some valid points about going to a centre trial and putting any club on the entry form and at that same trial did you have to show your ACU Licence, I very much doubt it.
I sometimes wonder how many people actually have a licence when competing, there will be people saying "ah well they won't be covered for accidental injury" I dont think people care.
So is it down to the volunteer secretary to check licences and those that haven't cough up the 3 quid daily ACU Licence fee and then fill out extra forms to send in the money to Rugby maybe, just maybe if collected that goes into club funds? Would you blame them?
I used to show my licence once a year at the SSDT haven't been asked since 2007.
So no real solution unless you scrap the daily licence fee and each club check the riders licence when entering and that will not happen, I could also see entries plummeting and more people just going out with a few mates to ride.
So if you want it FREE ride Centre trials make up a club and number, don't hurt yourself and you will be fine.

Disclaimer: I have both licence and membership of 2 clubs.
If you can't beat em......get stickier tyres!!

Yorkshire War Cry....HOW MUCH??

#9 Nigel Dabster

    Advanced Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 6,573 posts
  • Location:Miton Keynes
  • Bike:Gas Gas Bultaco 340
  • Club:Milton Buzzard MCC,Richmond MC

Posted 18 May 2011 - 04:23 PM

View PostPHB, on 18 May 2011 - 03:12 PM, said:

we dont issue membership cards and i dont know of any yorkshire centre club that does ,but some clubs might, its hard enough getting £15 a trial out of some riders never mind putting a few extra quid on the entry fee, plus it may only be a fee quid to be a member but that money goes into buying flags scorecards etc, clubs are not charities.
richmond mc issue cards are they in the yorkshire centre?

#10 John Collins

    Advanced Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 349 posts
  • Bike:bultaco

Posted 18 May 2011 - 06:55 PM

PHB puts in bold IF ITS NOT BROKEN DONT FIX IT (ACU)

I will try to answer:

I am afraid it is rather broke – or rather certainly not really for modern times?

We live in an age where we can tax our car, fill in our income tax return , order most things including our weekly shopping, all on line. We can get our driving licence, memberships of most things, book our air flights etc all on line. But when we wish to take out ACU Registration or Licence- we have to move back to the old fashioned ways

There are some problems.

While some clubs meet on a weekly basis ( mine does) others do not. Add in that this day and age people may be working and not able to get there, and also one can attend , and find that on that particular night the Official you need may not be there etc

So – for many the answer has been to fill in the form – and send it to Club Sec – along perhaps with the Club membership money – and then leave the dear old Club Sec to stamp them up and post them to the ACU. This all takes time.

Apart form someone ( Club Sec having to do this – and usually a lump at a particular time of year) and apart from fact that Club Sec may have further expenditure on postage etc ( not that cheap at present) – common sense and human nature tell us that the Club Sec should not be expected to do all this and trot to Post every day, so obviously they tend to “ bundle” them and post when they have a batch or the time to do so. Not all I know, but certainly some.

Problem – this time varies – and I can tell you for sure that at the start of 2011, some licence/registration forms were arriving many weeks ( in one case months) after the rider had done his bit

Result – Rider turns up at an event , truthfully and honestly states he has sent it all in – but weeks later it has not arrived.

Now – where the system works, and Club Sec’s have a good handle on it, fine – we see that this can carry on

BUT: Where it is not working, and where it is reasonable to assume the ACU should be trying to move out of the dark ages . It is surely reasonable to look if there are alternatives ?

The big big problem is not breaking the link between Club and member – which was that posed originally by Nigel . Some clubs are not that bothered about the membership fee ( they may collect it later or use Club membership cards to check at events etc) - others are worried – not only about loss of revenue, but it is also nice to see members now and again, if only when they want something i.e. form signed.

So, what has actually happened is that all Clubs have received a “ Consultation” paper , outlining about 5 options and inviting any other ideas, and obviously the comments, like we have read in these posts.

Since I just left short trousers I have always heard how the ACU should be speaking/asking/communicating with its riders – so here we have it.

Consultation not only with Centres and Committee’s, but with the Clubs

Again , frankly if the only worry some have is that they have Insurance ( and most of the post about this is nonscence - as it fails to consider what happens if a bike for example lands on a third party such as a spectator - which is why in every Trial we all avail ourselves of £30 million Third Part Liability cover - via our entry fee) , then those people dop not give a toss about Clubs anyway, and assume that the events we ride in must just appear out of eteher rather than a hard working Club put them on?

As I stated at outset, we all appreciate the link needed between Club and rider, but this applies in many walks of life, we need to move forward, and frankly – if we are using the present system just to force/ blackmail riders into paying the relatively small Club fee’s( for which the hard working Club people do a lot of work) - we probably do have a much wider problem and some worries for then future?

#11 Pete_Scorpa3

    Advanced Member

  • Site Supporter
  • 1,440 posts
  • Location:Evesham, Worcs.
  • Bike:Scorpa SY250
  • Club:Stratford-Upon-Avon MC&LCC

Posted 18 May 2011 - 08:08 PM

View PostJohn Collins, on 18 May 2011 - 06:55 PM, said:

PHB puts in bold IF ITS NOT BROKEN DONT FIX IT (ACU)

I will try to answer:

I am afraid it is rather broke – or rather certainly not really for modern times?

We live in an age where we can tax our car, fill in our income tax return , order most things including our weekly shopping, all on line. We can get our driving licence, memberships of most things, book our air flights etc all on line. But when we wish to take out ACU Registration or Licence- we have to move back to the old fashioned ways

There are some problems.

While some clubs meet on a weekly basis ( mine does) others do not. Add in that this day and age people may be working and not able to get there, and also one can attend , and find that on that particular night the Official you need may not be there etc

So – for many the answer has been to fill in the form – and send it to Club Sec – along perhaps with the Club membership money – and then leave the dear old Club Sec to stamp them up and post them to the ACU. This all takes time.

Apart form someone ( Club Sec having to do this – and usually a lump at a particular time of year) and apart from fact that Club Sec may have further expenditure on postage etc ( not that cheap at present) – common sense and human nature tell us that the Club Sec should not be expected to do all this and trot to Post every day, so obviously they tend to “ bundle” them and post when they have a batch or the time to do so. Not all I know, but certainly some.

Problem – this time varies – and I can tell you for sure that at the start of 2011, some licence/registration forms were arriving many weeks ( in one case months) after the rider had done his bit

Result – Rider turns up at an event , truthfully and honestly states he has sent it all in – but weeks later it has not arrived.

Now – where the system works, and Club Sec’s have a good handle on it, fine – we see that this can carry on

BUT: Where it is not working, and where it is reasonable to assume the ACU should be trying to move out of the dark ages . It is surely reasonable to look if there are alternatives ?

The big big problem is not breaking the link between Club and member – which was that posed originally by Nigel . Some clubs are not that bothered about the membership fee ( they may collect it later or use Club membership cards to check at events etc) - others are worried – not only about loss of revenue, but it is also nice to see members now and again, if only when they want something i.e. form signed.

So, what has actually happened is that all Clubs have received a “ Consultation” paper , outlining about 5 options and inviting any other ideas, and obviously the comments, like we have read in these posts.

Since I just left short trousers I have always heard how the ACU should be speaking/asking/communicating with its riders – so here we have it.

Consultation not only with Centres and Committee’s, but with the Clubs

Again , frankly if the only worry some have is that they have Insurance ( and most of the post about this is nonscence - as it fails to consider what happens if a bike for example lands on a third party such as a spectator - which is why in every Trial we all avail ourselves of £30 million Third Part Liability cover - via our entry fee) , then those people dop not give a toss about Clubs anyway, and assume that the events we ride in must just appear out of eteher rather than a hard working Club put them on?

As I stated at outset, we all appreciate the link needed between Club and rider, but this applies in many walks of life, we need to move forward, and frankly – if we are using the present system just to force/ blackmail riders into paying the relatively small Club fee’s( for which the hard working Club people do a lot of work) - we probably do have a much wider problem and some worries for then future?

John,

Our club have yet to discuss the options, so I am only speaking from a personal point of view.

As a membership secretary I feel that it is MOST important for the ACU to confirm club membership prior to issuing the licence (registration)otherwise some riders will simply not bother to join a club.
It's not my place to post the five options on this forum, however option one includes the following statement -

"Clubs will be advised, on a weekly basis, of the names and contact details of each new or renewing member to enable them to chase up subscription payments."

In recent years I have sent every paid up club member a membership form and an addressed return envelope as soon as the ACU licence (registration) forms appear in the post. Mid/late November time.
This encourages the members to join the club and get their licence ready for the new year. The deadline for this is set for the Ralph Varden trial around the 9th of December when I send all of the completed forms to the ACU in a single recorded delivery envelope. These applications are processed and returned before the new year, an excellent service from the licencing dept.

My concern is this. Even sending out the forms with a return envelope to almost 100 members, I only get about 40 returned before Christmas, the remainder trickle back in the new year, some as late as May!

Now bearing this in mind, and remembering that currently riders need their application forms signed prior to getting their licences, what chance will I have of getting club membership fees under a system where I have to "chase up" the money after the licences have been issued?

I am all in favour of an online system, but I feel strongly that club memberships must be confirmed prior to the licence being issued.

Of course, one of the other options is to remove the need to join a club at all. This would make the ACU's job a lot easier and have no effect on their income, so I can't blame them for suggesting that idea.

As an aside, we do issue every paid up member with a current membership card each year.

Pete

#12 Highland Lassie

    Advanced Member

  • Site Supporter
  • 776 posts
  • Location:Croy, North of Scotland
  • Bike:Aprilia RS250, TY250
  • Club:Edinburgh & District MC

Posted 18 May 2011 - 09:13 PM

View PostGIZZA5, on 18 May 2011 - 03:42 PM, said:

I used to show my licence once a year at the SSDT haven't been asked since 2007.
Irrelevant I know, but for the avoidance of any doubt, that's because he hasn't ridden since 2007, not because we've stopped checking every licence! :)

#13 John Collins

    Advanced Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 349 posts
  • Bike:bultaco

Posted 19 May 2011 - 12:00 AM

Yes – all that fully accepted , and is the reason why on line licensing has/is taking so long

However, you quote examples of a system that you are happy with and have developed , and are obviously efficient at. Can you be sure that this works for every or even the majority of Clubs? And can we be sure that the riders who do not bother to reply and join your club do not just take a flyer and not bother?

In all discussion on this topic, there is an obvious tendancy for those who have no problem, or are happy with the situation to wish to retain the present system - but as I stated in last post, the evidence is that there is a problem , and we are also aware of many riders just not bothering , and while I know that many will say that they must always be checked and so on , and riders without them should not be allowed to ride etc in the real world we have what we have, and they do.

More importantly, if we all look around our Clubs, are those Club Sec’s all going to be willing to do this in a few years? Or for that matter how easy will it be to actually find a Club Sec willing to take on the tasks? I am afraid I do not see people in a long line to do these jobs – and possibly this enhances the view that the Club membership and particularly loyalty and appreciation of what Clubs do is waning, and if the only method we have of making riders join their Club is to make them present a form for signing , perhaps that is the issue that really needs looking at

I suspect many riders reading this belong to more than one Club? , I know I did for many years , for varying reasons.

Logically they only need one Club to sign their form, therefore there must be a reason or advantage in then joining others? Possibly Closed to Club events, Championships, Appreciation of work done and so on. If there are reasons for joining more than one Club – these reasons must remain regardless of any licence form?

There are other possibilities given eg Clubs issued with a batch of dedicated numbers or codes – and when a member joins club either by attending, phoning or email etc he/she would be given their own code number which would be typed onto the on line licence application. The Club signature could and would still be valid for those wishing to stay with this method

Another train of thought would be that while a rider gets back his/her bit of plastic ie Registration card - it is only validated – or valid if you like if it has a Club membership card with it? Could even be stuck to back of it or put in a plastic wallet i.e. you would have to “ flash” both sides instead of just one?

There are several options – hence the need and invitation for ideas, but I still repeat that if we wish to move forward, then on line licencing is needed for a variety of reasons , and hopefully a way can be found of maintaining the link to a Club – but at the end of the day it needs positive thought and consultation

Please note I have not dwelled very much on the fact that it is difficult in the extreme to accurately tell if Club Sec signatures etc ( they change) are always genuine – and while I know that there should be Club stamps used, this is not always the case, or at least they certainly do not always arrive with these on them

Finally, Finally, the question asked at the outset was would riders still join a Club if they did not need that signature. All the replies are valid and make good points, but there are a hell of a lot of other riders out there, and they need to reply so we can all actually see a clearer picture

#14 totalshell

    Advanced Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 1,460 posts
  • Location:lancashire (just)
  • Bike:Audit due...
  • Club:YCMCC, Red Rose, SAFC, Clarks Commandos

Posted 19 May 2011 - 01:36 PM

at the moment i have an acu trials registration card, i also have club membership cards for 4 clubs ( annual subs between 5 and 15 pounds) there is absolutely no need to link the two i'll join which ever clubs put on decent trials and or whose aims i support. the nessecity as john pointed out for the club secretary to sign each form is a throw back to the days of black and white telly and pathe news.
for a beginner it must certainly provide a barrier.. how many times has the question ''what do i need for my first trial?'' been raised on these very pages. make it easy for clubs secretarys then all you have to di is flash your photo registration card and club membership when signing on and bingo..
We few .. We happy few...

http://pre65trials.blogspot.com/

#15 chewy

    Advanced Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 954 posts
  • Location:Bristol ..UK
  • Bike:Beta Evo 200
  • Club:Kingswood MCC......Wessex

Posted 19 May 2011 - 03:52 PM

It's a bit of a Hazy memory for me but I seem to recall that our Centre is made up of clubs and voting "rights" on Centre matters are based upon club membership. This is another reason for keeping the clubs in this particular loop. Surely it wouldn't be difficult for the ACU to "trade off" printing a particular ACU card holders club & Centre on the card after the club has validated his/her membership leaving it up to the clubs to choose how to raise membership and subscriptions. In brief there are still a few people left at club level who are prepared to work for nothing more than the glory of thier particular club and of course the sport (because it won't work at all without them) so why doesn't the ACU offer these people a benifit (less work ?) for changing the way they work.





1 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users