I stiil say why was it a controverial win?
Simon dropped the same amount of marks as Pete carson {who is also a friend} who was riding a macdonald cub, is that not controversial?
I dont think it is.
I sometimes ride against Pete and alot of the other local lads who also ride Macdonald cubs in the Unit class at local events, and to be quite honest I enjoy putting my C15 ,{what is now regarded as a heavy weight} bike up against them. You go to work all week and if tricking your bike up blows your skirt up (I know it does mine} Its all good. Its not controversial.
Regarding the ACU I dont think they are really that bothered. The rules are no discs and correct me if Im wrong but all parts must be "period". Check Nigel Birketts works Suzuki complete with yam mono wheels forks swingarm of which I dont have a problem with as with Chris Koch's cotswold. Both have two shocks ,drum brakes and are air cooled.
Remember you could still buy a Godden framed Majesty off Shirty well after the mono's came out so you could say all parts are period. My Majesty has a Mono front end but with a new billet yoke to bring the front in a bit. controversial? regarding the ignition thats, IT400 electronic from early eighties. Carb is 28mikuni vm circa 2007. Air in tyres is from last week!
I agree with Woody in that we ride bikes we have an affinity for, I grew up watching Kicksart and Junior Kickstart I cant remember seeing an Ariel or a Matchless compete at any event in fact my C15 is older than me! But why is it seen to be ok for the died in the wool pre 65 boys to trick there bikes beyond recognition{ of which I still have no problem}yet when a twinshock gets the treatment its "controversial". Yet when the sections these bikes were designed for become a bit tasty the cry "these arn't pre 65 sections the're twinshock!" is heard. Whats that all about?
You compare a standard 70's twinshock to a modern pre 65, the 70's twinshock is like riding a 5 bar gate ,we might not ride very often but we still love em.
My opinion is this if it gets feet on pegs at the weekends whats the problem? we have far bigger things to worry about like the current state of the economy, losing land not enough observers etc.
Ps cant wait till the recession ends so I can order my macdonald Cub